Have you discovered DaySpring? They have a wonderful selection of Christian-themed gifts, stationary and much more.
Right now they have a huge clearance section online with deep discounts on Art, Toys, Home Decor, and Christmas items. I see several ideas for teacher gifts this year!
Plus, through 12/31/09, you can get FREE shipping with a minimum $10.00 purchase. Use coupon code NOSHIPCHARGE upon check out.
Thanks, Frugal Creativity!